To The Victoria Falls
Development of the Victoria Falls
Recent History
The following text is adapted from the forthcoming third edition of 'Footsteps Through Time - A History of Travel and Tourism to the Victoria Falls', researched and written by Peter Roberts and due for publication at the end of 2024. Please visit the Zambezi Book Company website for more information.
Road to Recovery
Zimbabwe's tourism sector showed strong signs of recovery in 2022, with half-year figures recording 352,719 arrivals, against 164,062 in the first six months of 2021, with overseas visitors reaching 130,413 against 40,321 recorded over the same period in 2021 (Zimbabwe Tourism Authority, 2022b). In August 2022 it was reported that peak season arrivals at the Victoria Falls Airport were returning close to the levels of 2019 (Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs, August, 2022b).
A third-quarter (January-September) Z.T.A. tourism report showed further signs of recovery with national arrivals to Zimbabwe reaching 701,278 over the first nine months of the year, up from 261,415 over the same period in 2021 (Zimbabwe Tourism Authority, 2023a). Full year national arrivals reached 1,043,781, including 350,500 overseas arrivals. Analysis of annual room occupancy rates showed the resort’s 1,256 hotel rooms achieved occupancy levels of 36 percent and a selection of 29 key lodges and camps, representing 381 rooms, 30 percent over the year (Zimbabwe Tourism Authority, 2023b).
A total of 214,034 visitors were recorded to the south-bank Rainforest over 2022, including 115,024 international visitors. Figures for the Zambezi National Park indicated 147,633 visitors, including 65,665 international visitors (Zimbabwe Tourism Authority, 2023b). Zambian authorities recorded 167,256 visitors to the Falls during 2022, including 33,742 international visitors. The Mosi-oa-Tunya National Park recorded 14,743 visitors (Zambia Ministry of Tourism, 2024).
The figures indicate a combined total of 381,290 visitors to the Falls over the year. No visitor statistics were reported in the 2024 State of Conservation report to U.N.E.S.C.O. (Joint Site Management Committee, 2024).
Cataract Island Tours Launched
In April 2022 Zambezi Crescent, managers of the Victoria Falls River Lodge, relaunched the controversial proposal to operate tours to Cataract Island and swimming in the natural plunge pools on the lip of the Falls (as per the popular tours to Livingstone Island and the Devil’s Pool operated from the Zambian side). The tours were launched with a new website and social media campaign, but without public or local stakeholder disclosure and consultation, no supporting Environmental and Social Impact Assessment (specifically requested by U.N.E.S.C.O. in 2017) and without notifying U.N.E.S.C.O. (Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs, June 2022).
"A fully guided experience including a short boat trip across the calm waters of the channel to Cataract Island. Once disembarked, a guided tour of the Island follows, including time to explore the new section of Victoria Falls that is busy forming. Enjoy plenty of free time for optional swimming in the warm, clear pools on the face of the falls, or to explore some of the most spectacular scenery that nature has to offer." (Cataract Pools publicity information)
Sreenshot from Cataract Pool website
The protected refuge of Cataract Island is the last remaining area of the Falls Rainforest untouched by tourist foot-fall and associated trampling impacts on the fragile ground flora. The launch of the tours stimulated another online petition against the use of the island for tourism and attracted widespread negative media publicity, adding to concerns over the conservation of the site and effective control of tourism development.
Read more: Keep Victoria Falls Wild - Cataract Island Tours Launched (April 2022, external site, opens in a new window)
Riverside Developments
During 2022 two new tourism developments along the south-bank Zambezi Drive, just upstream of the Falls and within the upstream river extension of the Victoria Falls National Park and World Heritage Site, raised further concerns over the Park Authority's management of the Victoria Falls.
In April 2022 work started clearing bush, scrub and trees from a riverside site just above the Devil’s Cataract, outside the fenced Victoria Falls visitor park but still within the upstream river extension of the Victoria Falls National Park and within the World Heritage Site, for a rumoured restaurant development.
In June the developers, Victoria Falls Investments, claimed that a full E.S.I.A. had been completed for the proposal, yet there was no public disclosure or open stakeholder consultation on the proposal, core elements of the E.S.I.A. process. It was also claimed that the development was within the ‘Medium Ecologically Sensitive Zone’ (M.E.S.Z.) of the World Heritage Site, and therefore an allowed development. It is clear, however, that the text descriptions of the management zones in the agreed Joint Integrated Management Plans include this section riverside fringe within the ‘Highly Ecologically Sensitive Zone’ (H.E.S.Z.) which allows no new development.
The construction caused huge local controversy and widespread negative social media reaction, stimulated the establishment of an online petition against the over-development of the Falls, including the launch of Cataract Island tours (and which gained close to 20,500 signatures by the end of August 2023), and a legal challenge against the development by a group of concerned local residents. In the face of much negative reaction the Baines Restaurant opened in June 2023 (Keep Victoria Falls Wild, 2024). As at the end of 2024 the legal case has still to be heard.
Another new development, the ‘Rock Pool’ Bar has been development by the Park Authority just upstream from the Baines Restaurant and again located within the H.E.S.Z. ‘no development zone.’ First revealed with the construction of a small brick building which appeared in early in 2022, further structures have since been developed including associated landscaped lawns and car parking areas. There has been no E.I.A. process and no detailed disclosure to U.N.E.S.C.O. The development opened in December 2022, offering bar, picnic and braai (barbecue) facilities. Complaints were raised by residents over the number of people (up to 200) and excessive number of vehicles gathered along Zambezi Drive, with a loud-speaker system and bar operating until late into the evening (Keep Victoria Falls Wild, 2023).
Construction within National Park concessions is restricted to semi-permanent facilities, yet these new developments, along with other recent concession developments (including the Sian Simba River Lodge and The Lookout Cafe) have been constructed in brick and cement (Keep Victoria Falls Wild, 2023).
Read more: Keep Victoria Falls Wild - Zambezi Drive Developments (external site, opens in a new window)
Keep Victoria Falls Wild
The wave of tourism development proposals encroaching on the south bank of the World Heritage Site resulted in the evolution of the ‘Save Siansimba’ campaign into ‘Keep Victoria Falls Wild’ (www.keepvictoriafallswild.com), aimed at raising awareness of the issues surrounding the World Heritage Site, tourism development pressures and highlighting unsuitable developments. At the same time a group of local residents launched a legal challenge against the issuing of permits for several of the tourism developments threatening the Victoria Falls and Zambezi National Parks, including the controversial launch of tours to Cataract Island and riverside restaurant above the Falls (Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs, August 2022a).
Documents presented by the developer of the riverside restaurant to the Zimbabwean High Court as part of the legal challenge against the development included the E.I.A. document prepared for the project. Significantly, the document is confused as to whether the development site is even within the W.H.S, the report making five references to the site being outside of the W.H.S. (varying from being adjacent to up to 2-3 km away) and only one correct reference to the site being located within the W.H.S, but critically incorrectly identified as being within the M.E.S.Z. (Environmental Guardian Services, 2021; Keep Victoria Falls Wild, 2023).
Also released was the authorisation letter from Dr Mangwanya, Director General for the Zimbabwe Parks and Wildlife Management Authority (Zimbabwe Parks and Wildlife Management Authority, June 2021), personally approving the development. Dr Mangwanya incorrectly identifies the location as within the ‘M.E.S.Z.’ and therefore erroneously concludes that it was a permitted development, describing the proposal a ‘semi-permanent restaurant.’ Despite these errors, the E.I.A. approval for this project has not been withdrawn and the restaurant remains operational.
At a National Park planning meeting, held with local stakeholders at the Victoria Falls on 9th May 2022, Park representatives declined the opportunity to present further information on the wave of new tourism development proposals currently threatening the Falls and surrounding areas, indicating that "lease allocations will be discussed at a different forum" (ZPWMA, May 2022, external download, opens in new window). This was in the face of widespread criticism from stakeholders on lack of transparency in the allocation of concessions, substandard ESIA reports and limited public disclosure and stakeholder consultation.
Read more: Keep Victoria Falls Wild - Victoria Falls Resort (external site, opens in a new window)